Capital Hill Has Cracked Its Foundation

I spent a good part of my life around things that were built to hold weight.

Mines, pipe trenches, job sites. You learn early in that kind of work that a structure doesn’t fail all at once. It tells you first, if you know how to listen.

A door starts to stick in its frame. A hairline crack runs out from the corner of a window. A spot in the floor goes a little soft under your boot. Most folks see those things and reach for a paint brush. A man who has poured footings sees them and heads for the basement, because trouble upstairs almost always starts down below.

I’ve been looking at the election numbers this week, and I want to talk to you about what I see. I see a house that’s crumbling, and under it, a foundation that has cracked. And I’ll tell you right up front, I think there’s hope in that. Stay with me and I’ll show you why.

Start with the House of Representatives. As of September 23, Decision Desk HQ gives the Democrats a 72 percent chance of taking it, with a projected 232 seats. It only takes 218. A team at Cornell whose model has called fourteen straight congressional elections gives them about eight chances in ten. The betting markets go higher than both. That’s the house, and the walls are leaning where the whole street can see them.

Now the Senate. The Senate was supposed to be the foundation, the part poured deep enough to hold no matter what the weather did upstairs. Republicans sit on 53 seats. The Democrats need to gain four and lose none, which is a tall order in any year. A few weeks ago, most people figured the Republicans would hold it. I figured the same, and I was wrong.

That same Decision Desk model now gives the Democrats a 55 percent chance at the Senate. Nate Silver’s team reports the Democrats lead the polling in all six states most likely to decide it. Those states are Texas, Iowa, Ohio, Maine, Michigan, and Alaska. When Texas shows up on that list, you’ve got a crack in the footing.

Michigan was supposed to be a place the Republicans could pick up a seat. This week one of the big rating outfits moved it toward the Democrats. Iowa slid to a coin flip. Kansas got shakier. When Kansas starts to wobble, the settling has reached ground everybody thought was solid.

A lot of you have asked me a fair question. Can the party fix this before November by removing the man at the top? The honest answer is no. Removing a president takes 67 senators, which means about twenty Republicans voting against their own man. It has never happened in our history, and it won’t happen in six weeks.

And even if it did, history says it wouldn’t save them. Nixon resigned in August of 1974, three months before the midterms. That November, his party lost 48 seats in the House anyway. Taking the man out didn’t take the damage out. The voters remembered who had carried him.

So where’s the hope? It’s in what comes after November 3, in a stretch of time most people never think about. Between the election and the new Congress in January, the old Congress keeps working. They call it the lame duck. The members who lost are still sitting there, and so are the ones who retired, and every one of them still has a vote.

Here’s what makes that time different. Those folks have nothing left to protect. There’s no next primary to survive and no angry crowd to keep happy. Nobody is counting heads on them anymore. I’ve watched men on a job site go quiet for years and then say exactly what they thought on their last week. People are like that. Fear runs the show until the fear runs out.

And here’s the part that works for you. In a 53-seat Senate, it doesn’t take twenty Republicans to put the brakes on. It takes four. Four votes can stop a bad appointment. Four can kill a bill. Four can pull the reins on a war. You don’t need a revolt. You need four people who finally stopped being afraid.

History says that kind of courage tends to show up after a bad election, not before one. Before the vote, every member is doing arithmetic on their own seat. After the vote, the arithmetic is done. That’s when you find out who was holding back because they had to, and who was holding back because they wanted to.

Where I come from, you don’t fix a cracked foundation by painting the walls. You dig down to it. You shore it up, and you pour new footing where the old one failed. It’s slow, and it’s dirty, and nobody claps for it. But it’s the only repair that holds.

This country has good footing under it. It was poured a long time ago by people who knew what they were doing. They built in checks, they built in balance, and they built in a way for ordinary people to stand up and say enough. That way is called an election, and it’s six weeks out.

Keep this in mind, though. A forecast is not a vote. The numbers show you where the cracks are running, but nothing is settled until the ballots are counted. The repair starts with you showing up.

I’m not watching for the house to fall. I’m watching for somebody to go down to the basement with a flashlight and tell the truth about what they find. For the first time in a good while, I think somebody might.

the-faust-baseline-public-release-1Download

” Attic Thoughts”-library – Intelligent People Assume Nothing

This post was drafted with AI governed assistance and reviewed and directed by Michael S. Faust Sr. before publication.