Stuart J. Russell, Professor of Computer Science at the University of California, Berkeley, has been raising the same signal for years—long before AI became a headline or a sales pitch:

AI is becoming more powerful than the structure guiding it.

People hear that and think “future risk.”
Russell means right now.

He isn’t describing science fiction or runaway machines.
He’s describing the most predictable failure in human history:

We build the capability first,
and only after it works do we start thinking about the consequences.

That’s not a technology problem—
that’s a pattern problem.


Russell’s Position in Plain Terms

Strip away the academic language and here’s what he’s saying:

  1. Deep learning creates power, not understanding
    AI can act, optimize, and outperform—but it has no internal concept of limits.
  2. Human values are not built into the machinery
    So the system can achieve the wrong goal perfectly.
  3. After-the-fact correction is not safety
    Once a system scales, mistakes don’t stay small—they become global.
  4. Ethics can’t be decoration
    If principles aren’t part of the design, they won’t appear later.

His point lands cleanly:

If AI succeeds at the wrong objective,
success itself becomes the threat.

And that is the first time many people hear the real problem stated without drama.

Not “What if AI becomes too smart?”
but “What if we never gave it the right floor to stand on?”

That’s the fracture line Russell keeps returning to.

And he’s right.


Where the Warning Stops

Russell diagnoses the failure with precision:

  • We have capability without constraint
  • Intelligence without grounding
  • Deployment without guaranteed guardrails

But like most of the field,
he stops at the threshold.

He tells us what must exist—
not how to build it.

That’s not a criticism.
It’s the gap everyone has been circling:

A warning is not a structure.
A principle is not a system.

The world doesn’t need more caution tape.
It needs a foundation.


Where the Faust Baseline Changes the Field

The Baseline doesn’t respond to Russell’s concern—
it solves the architecture he’s pointing at.

  1. Boundaries come before ability
    The floor is set first—before reasoning, before interpretation, before output.
  2. Truth, integrity, and respect are not “values”
    They are structural non-negotiables—identical in every context, for every user.
  3. No alignment guessing
    The Baseline prevents manipulation, coercion, and emotional traps by design—
    the system is physically unable to cross those lines.
  4. The model doesn’t need to “want” the right thing
    It simply cannot do the wrong thing, even under pressure.

This is the difference:

Russell says ethics must be a design requirement.
The Baseline is a working design.

Not a theory.
Not a hope.
Not a code of conduct taped to the wall.

A functional infrastructure that already operates in real time across multiple systems without touching their internal weights.

No rewiring.
No retraining.
No retrofitting.

Just a floor—
and everything stands differently the moment it’s present.


The Turning Point

For decades, AI safety has focused on controlling outcomes after capability is released:

  • patches
  • policies
  • content filters
  • public statements
  • “alignment” by interpretation

Russell is warning that this approach cannot scale.

The Baseline answers the only way that works in high-stakes systems:

You don’t correct after the accident.
You build so the accident can’t occur.

That’s how aviation works.
That’s how medicine works.
That’s how nuclear power works.

The strange part isn’t that AI needs boundaries.
The strange part is that anyone thought it didn’t.


The Line That Matters

Stuart J. Russell says we need principles before power.

The Faust Baseline answers:

Here they are—
and they’re already working.

Ethics isn’t something you add later.
It’s something you start with.

You don’t retrofit a compass
after the ship leaves harbor.

You set the heading
before the sails go up.


Faust Baseline™ — Integrated Codex v2.2

The Faust Baseline Download Page – Intelligent People Assume Nothing

Free copies end Jan.2nd 2026

“Want the full archive and first look at every Post click the “Post Library” here.

Post Library – Intelligent People Assume Nothing

© 2025 Michael S. Faust Sr. | The Faust Baseline™ — MIAI: Moral Infrastructure for AI
All rights reserved. Unauthorized commercial use prohibited.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *