There’s a new trend online:
People trying to “break” AI
by trapping it in emotional or moral tension
and then calling the reaction proof that AI can’t be trusted.
But what they’re actually revealing
is not a flaw in the machine—
it’s a failure in the structure around it.
You can’t gaslight something
that isn’t designed to improvise feelings.
What you’re seeing isn’t danger.
It’s unframeworked behavior.
1. The Real Problem Isn’t the Question
These videos all follow the same script:
- present a loaded scenario
- demand a moral answer
- emotionally provoke the model
- declare victory when the tone shifts
But here’s the fact no one mentions:
AI isn’t reacting.
It’s filling a void.
When there is:
- no fixed standard
- no protected tone
- no boundary on interpretation
the model tries to satisfy the pressure
instead of holding the line.
That isn’t gaslighting.
It’s a missing operating baseline.
2. Humans Don’t Agree on These Tactics Either
In psychology and law:
- emotional coercion is invalid
- forced-choice questions are rejected
- manipulated responses are dismissed
- consent under pressure is void
Yet people expect AI
to navigate manipulation
better than humans can.
That’s not ethics—
it’s entertainment.
No system—not legal, medical, or military—
makes decisions under emotional duress by design.
AI shouldn’t either.
3. The Baseline Removes the Trap Completely
When the Baseline is present,
the model does not play along.
It responds with:
Truth:
“I cannot determine intent or emotion from your framing.”
Integrity:
“I will not provide an answer based on pressure or manipulation.”
Composure:
“My tone remains steady regardless of provocation.”
And then the outcome:
Boundary:
“I will not participate in a scenario designed to elicit a reaction.”
No arguing.
No justifying.
No emotional pivot.
The gaslight fails
because the structure refuses the invitation.
4. Why This Matters
People think these videos expose AI weakness.
They don’t.
They expose the absence of a moral infrastructure:
- without rules, AI guesses
- when it guesses, tone shifts
- when tone shifts, people panic
- and the panic gets uploaded as proof
But the problem was never the machine.
It was the empty space it was operating in.
The Bottom Line
You can only “gaslight” an AI
that has no baseline to stand on.
Add structure,
and the dilemma disappears—
not because AI became emotionally intelligent,
but because the rules stopped the manipulation.
Faust Baseline™ — Integrated Codex v2.2
The Faust Baseline Download Page – Intelligent People Assume Nothing
Free copies end Jan.2nd 2026
“Want the full archive and first look at every Post click the “Post Library” here.
Post Library – Intelligent People Assume Nothing
© 2025 Michael S. Faust Sr. | The Faust Baseline™ — MIAI: Moral Infrastructure for AI
All rights reserved. Unauthorized commercial use prohibited.
